Chuck Carnevale

Avatar
  • updated
  • Under review

Terrible decision by SA to disallow Chuck Carnevale FastGraphs videos from your site.  This was one of my favorite analysts and will result in me seeking him out on other sites and REDUCE my time (and clicks) on SA.

Avatar
Dividends_Wrangler

Agree.  Would appreciate an explanation from SA.

Avatar
Ziminy

I found SA because of him.  This is just one more sign of the downward direction of this website. I will follow Chuck elsewhere and come to Seeking Alpha a lot less.  So long...and thanks for all the fish!

Avatar
mermaid1

What is going on with Seeking Alpha? Chuck Carnevale is one of its most valuable commentators -- unbiased, informative, not using his site only to push a premium subscription --  and he is a major reason why I use SA. Well I guess I'll follow him elsewhere and use SA less. It has been turning into a promotional site for subscriptions in any case.

Avatar
anonymous

Chuck Carnaval is clearly one of the best analysts on your site. It is a travesty that he has been barred from publishing his high-quality research and analysis. It makes me question the veracity of seeking Alpha. 

Avatar
uteskier

I agree that this is a terrible decision by SA to disallow Chuck Carnevale FastGraphs videos from your site. Chuck is one of your best analysts and will result in me seeking him out on other sites and REDUCE my time (and clicks) on SA

Avatar
KORMIX

This is a disturbing decision by SA.  Although I have been considering a premium membership, blocking one of the most insightful contributors, makes me question the motivation of the SA team.  Obviously the Fast Graph videos highlight Fast Graphs and but that does not detract from SA but rather enhances it.  I am less likely to enroll in a premium membership if the SA team intentionally quashes high quality contributors due to  what they (may) see as potential competition. This decision should be reversed.

Avatar
mkaz1313

If Chuck Carnevale is out, I'm out.  Seems like SA is not paying attention to its readers and contributors.  

Avatar
Bob Holz

Forcing one of your all time favorite contributors to drop out is one of the most stupid ideas you guys have ever come up with.    As other(s) have noted, any hope by SA of having me (and many others) of signing-up for premium service is now gone.    Potential competition?   You have nothing like "Fast Graphs".    Unfortunately what I'm seeing as of late is more and more contributors blatantly pushing their "paid for" reports and less and less real investment research.

Avatar
dadick83

I agree with everyone above. Bad decision SA. I think you owe your subscribers a frank and COMPLETE explanation. I currently have two authors set for notification, chowder and chuck. Chowder was run off a while back and now chuck. I came to SA from my fastgraphs account. While I don’t watch every video, I read all the articles.  I’m going to give SA two weeks to make a public explanation. If that doesn’t happen or it doesn’t satisfy me as reasonable, I will be canceling my account. 

Avatar
ednissen

This is a most dismaying development. I am greatly disappointed, you reveal your only motivation.