Login issue

You have an old invalid email address for me that I tried to update when subscribing to the premium subscription.  I thought that I subscribed using my new email address, but your system still has me identified with my old email address.  And I cannot set a new password.  I am getting email to my new email address to reset my password, but your system is not allowing me to do so thinking that my old email address is still valid.

My current email address that I used to register should be markboeniger@gmail.com.  If you could check what is going on so that I can reset my password, that would be great.